SPOILER ALERT: Don’t read this post if you haven’t seen, or don’t want to know, details from the movie Rebel Moon: Part One – A Child of Fire (2023) streaming on Netflix.
When a peaceful settlement on the edge of a distant moon finds itself threatened by the armies of a tyrannical ruling force, Kora (Sofia Boutella), a mysterious stranger living among the villagers, becomes their best hope for survival. Tasked with finding trained fighters who will unite with her in making an impossible stand against the Mother World, Kora assembles a small band of warriors – outsiders, insurgents, peasants and orphans of war from different worlds who share a common need for redemption and revenge. As the shadow of an entire Realm bears down on the unlikeliest of moons, a battle over the fate of a galaxy is waged, and in the process, a new army of heroes is formed. -Synopsis (Netflix)
Remember when y’all dressed up in your parents’ clothes, shoes, etc. and acted like a grown-up? This new movie (streaming on Netflix) is NOT connected to Star Wars (as I’d assumed). I learned that Zack Snyder 1st conceived this as a Star Wars movie; he pitched it to Lucasfilm in 2012 (after it was sold to Disney). As many critics have noted, this is a take on Seven Samurai (1954) dir. by Akira Kurosawa. It’s basically style (SFX/action) over substance, though the CGI isn’t always impressive. I don’t know much re: Snyder’s work (though I know he is a divisive filmmaker); I saw Man of Steel at a (free) pre-screening in 2013. Nope, I would NOT have paid for that movie!
The cast incl. some actors who we (barely) know or haven’t seen before. Boutella (looking FAB at age 40- mad respect for that) is a French-Algerian actress w/ a strong background in dance/former model. I’ve ONLY seen her in Star Trek Beyond (2016) and an ep of Modern Love (2019); she doesn’t have range. This is the 1st time Ed Skrein (Adm. Atticus Noble) and Michiel Huisman (the lead farmer Gunnar) have worked together since Huisman (who is Danish) replaced Skrein (a Brit who resembles a young Jonathan Rhys Meyers) as Daario Naharis in Game of Thrones. Skrein (in the main baddie role) and his troupe of Mother World (NOT the Empire) soldiers are dressed in uniforms almost exactly like Nazis. Yikes, talk about a lazy shortcut for characterization! Huisman (though sporting bigger muscles/lusher hair than in previous roles) still comes off awkward and lacks charisma/screen presence. I recall that MANY viewers complained after he took on Daario; I also saw him in the ensemble drama Treme. As for Charlie Hunnam (Kai), he’s a baddie version of Han Solo w/ a man bun/twinkling blue eyes who speaks w/ an (exaggerated) Irish accent. Yes, Hunnam has charm, BUT that can’t save him here!
The fault should NOT totally fall on the actors’ (well-sculpted) shoulders; the script is uninspiring and the plot is thin. One viewer asked: “Was this written by AI?” LOL! There is a badass woman heroine (who can beat-up men 2x her size), innocent/peaceful farmers, cliched/nasty villains (incl. potential rapists), and a V little arc to the story. As w/ MANY Netflix series/movies, there are TOO many characters who are barely developed; the audience ends up caring little about their fates. As Kora gathers the diverse team of warriors (each w/ a different style), we wonder why they want to join this fight. Like many viewers commented, I wanted to see more of the hardened warrior (played by Djimon Hounsou) and the robot character, Jimmy (voiced by Anthony Hopkins), who has a good scene in the 1st act. I’m also NOT a fan of slow-mo and lens flares (why I quit watching ST: Discovery).
[1] Imagine you’re a twelve year old boy, having watched some cool movies for the first time five minutes ago, having your bootleg toys of popular franchises and smashing them together in dirt saying “and then” every couple of minutes. Now imagine you get tens, if not hundreds of millions of dollars to make that a movie.
Now imagine that being better than this.
[2] Other than the world design and effects, there really isn’t much else to salvage from it. In true Snyder style we’ve got lens flare and slow motion, but this time he’s dialed it up over the top. Some of the action scenes are absolutely ruined from way too much diving in and out of slow motion.
[3] The plot? Star Wars excuse aside, it’s a mess. The preposterousness of engaging with their Seven Samurai recruits at moments when each is faced with a crucial test is just lazy storytelling.
-Excerpts from IMDb reviews