A Woman With an Empty Heart… A Man With a Loaded Gun whose only chaperone was MURDER! -A tagline for the film
We start with the cop in the big city being called up for his violence. He’s a vicious cop, vicious to criminals because he can rationalize it. Criminals are criminals to him, they’re not people. So he’s sent out of the city, into the mountains. -A.I. Bezzerides, screenwriter
A cop from the city, Jim Wilson (Robert Ryan), is disciplined for his violent behavior by his boss, Capt. Brawley (Ed Begley). He’s sent to a small/mountain town where the local sheriff needs help to solve the case of a murdered girl. The father of the victim, Walter Brent (Ward Bond), is determined to find/kill whoever is responsible. While on the trail of the suspect, Jim and Mr. Brent come to the home of Mary Malden (Ida Lupino). She is keeping a secret, and though nearly blind, Mary can “see” that Jim has a troubled/lonely soul.
Mary: Tell me, how is it to be a cop?
Jim: You get so you don’t trust anybody.
Mary: [who is blind] You’re lucky. You don’t have to trust anyone. I do. I have to trust everybody.
Director Nicholas Ray and screenwriter A.I. Bezzerides researched the daily life and procedures of police in prep, incl. riding w/ detectives in Boston’s South End. The screenplay was developed from the novel Mad with Much Heart by Gerald Butler. The urban scenes were shot in L.A. while the country scenes (in real snow) were shot outside Denver in 2 small towns. Savvy viewers may’ve noticed that a hand-held camera was used to give a “live action” feel to some sequences (rare for the time)! Composer Bernard Hermann (one of the best of his field) wrote the score (which is V memorable). At around 30 mins (when Jim is driving upstate), the music heard was also used 8 yrs. later in Hitchcock’s North by Northwest (1959).
I hate film-makers who want long discussions with actors over a scene. An actor who doesn’t know what a scene he’s going to play is in the wrong profession. -Robert Ryan, actor
This is an unusual/compelling noir which delves into the dark side and the light side of man’s nature. This is also a fave of Scorsese and one of the influences for Taxi Driver (which I haven’t seen yet). I’ve watched this movie a few times in recent yrs; it’s like 2 movies in one- a gritty police procedural and a touching melodrama. Lupino (who directed for a few days when Ray got sick) doesn’t appear until 39 mins. into the story. Ryan and Lupino got along well on set; they create quiet tension onscreen (romantic potential). You can rent this on Amazon Prime Video.
[1] The process of humanization of Jim Wilson is depicted through his relationship with Mary and is very touching. Ida Lupino and Robert Ryan have great performances under the direction of Nicholas Ray in this credible story.
[2] Right from the outset, we are in no doubt that Nicholas Ray is about to take us on a noir journey. Herrmann’s pulse like score accompanies its nighttime opening, Diskant’s photography immediately painting a harsh city where life on the streets is tough.
[3] Ryan is terrific, a real powerhouse and believable performance, while Lupino beautifully realises Mary’s serene impact on Wilson and the counter opposite to the darkness within the picture. It’s a given really, but Herrmann’s score is potent, listen out for the opening, the crossover section from city to countryside and the rock face pursuit. While Ray directs with his customary knack of blending the grim with the almost poetic.
-Excerpts from IMDb reviews