The studio (20th C. Fox) put a LOT into this noir: 3-D and stereophonic sound for the few theatres equipped for that sound system. The early ’50s was a time of 3-D craze, as film historians noted. The plot is simple: An ill-tempered/hard-drinking oil millionaire, Donald Whitley Carson III (Robert Ryan), breaks his leg falling off his horse in the desert. He is left to die by his cheating wife, Geraldine (Rhonda Fleming- w/ NOT much to do) and her lover, Joseph Duncan (William Lundigan). This film (directed by Roy Wood Baker) was distributed on a double bill w/ Rawhide (1951), a Western starring Tyrone Power and Susan Hayward.
Ryan though that his performance here was one of his finest. It must’ve been a challenge to be acting (mostly) alone in such a harsh environment; we hear (in voiceover) his inner thoughts/fears. The original script had Duncan walking off to Mexico, never to be seen again, and Carson picking up his wife and heading to divorce court. Studio head Darryl F. Zanuck wanted more action, so the fight scene btwn Carson and Duncan was added at the end. There a few moments where the 3-D does makes the movie a BIT exciting. It’s NOT going to wow modern audiences much- LOL!
[1] The fascination of the story was the way in which all the characteristics which, at the start, had made Ryan so unlikeable gradually became sympathetic and, after a while, we became identified with the tense struggle to survive of this man whom we had begun by disliking and despising…
This was some achievement by writer, director and actor… Identification is essential to suspense… You must care about the character to share his dangers, and suspense vanishes the moment the tiny thought enters your mind: “He deserves what he gets.”
[2] ... this is Ryan’s film, and he’s top-notch. His thoughts come over as voice-over, and you’re pulling for him every step of the way, despite everyone describing him as unpleasant.
-Excerpts from IMDb reviews