In 1986 in Brooklyn, we meet the (dysfunctional/intellectual) Berkman family headed by prof/writer, Bernard (Jeff Daniels- then aged 50), and his wife/writer, Joan (Laura Linney- aged 40), who’ve recently decided to separate. Bernard is bitter, cheap, and arrogant; he has no time for “philistines” (ppl who don’t read the type of books/watch the movies he likes). Bernard published a successful novel in his 20s, BUT is having a tough time getting his recent work published. Joan (who has been unfaithful) is finally finding success as a writer; she has grown tired of her husband’s ways. Their sons- 17 y.o. Walt (Jesse Eisenberg) and 12 y.o. Frank (Owen Kline- son of Kevin Kline and Phoebe Cates)- take sides in the divorce. Walt leaves w/ Bernard for an apt in another neighborhood; he takes on his father’s opinions/style/values. The more quiet/introverted Frank stays w/ Joan in the family’s townhouse. It turns out that BOTH kids feel the separation deeply and start behaving uncharacteristically.
This indie (made 10 yrs. after Baumbach’s 1st feature) was screened at Sundance; it received 3 Golden Globe noms and a best screenplay Oscar nom. The budget for this indie film was around $1.5M – wow! Director/screenwriter, Noah Baumbach (at age 36), took inspo from docs, the French New Wave, Scorsese’s early films, and work of John Cassavetes. Several viewers (fans/critics) refer to this film as “the prequel to Marriage Story.” The boy protagonist of The Squid and the Whale– Walt (whose POV we see from)- could be viewed as the precursor to the adult Charlie of Marriage Story. Both characters are dealing w/ divorce in their respective families. Linney was given the script by Eric Stoltz in 2000, while they were filming The House of Mirth; she agreed to do the film immediately! Many of Bernard’s grad students are portrayed by Baumbach’s IRL friends; his father and younger brother also appear in the film.
My mom saw this movie quite a while ago and was impressed by it; she liked the fresh dialogue and thought the characters were unique. I know Daniels mainly from HBO’s The Newsroom and some (V thoughtful) interviews he has given on the craft/business of acting. Here, the veteran actor creates an unexpected version of “toxic masculinity,” as Bernard uses his brain (words) to manipulate those around him, rather than brawn (physical violence). The role of Walt suits Eisenberg (21 y.o. at the time of filming) to a tee; this was a few yrs. before he got the lead in The Social Network (2010).
[1] He [Bernard] has become a bitter, unfocused, pompous ass of a person, father, husband and professor. The inability to recapture the magic of his early writing success has caused him to look down on all other writers… whether they be Fitzgerald or his own wife. This is Daniels’ best work ever on screen and is at once, painful and a joy to behold.
Laura Linney plays his wife as a woman who loves her kids unequivocally and has a zest for life that her downbeat husband no longer shares. Her new found success as a writer sets her off on a trail of confidence and joy, all the while understanding that her family still needs her very much.
The kids really take the film to the next level. Jesse Eisenberg (brilliant in Roger Dodger) and Owen Kline (son of Kevin Kline and Phoebe Cates) are both scene stealers as they struggle in their own distinct ways with their separated parents and their continuance through adolescence.
[2] A word about the humor: don’t expect any big gags. In fact, in the interview Noah talks about how he had to tell the actors not to read their lines as if they’re funny. He didn’t intend it to be a comedy, but still (owing largely to the fantastic deadpan performances by Jeff Daniels & Jesse Eisenberg) you might find yourself cracking up at how plain bizarre everything is.
-Excerpts from IMDb reviews