Gatsby’s mansion on Long Island (as imagined by director Baz Luhrmann)
Most critics say that The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald is a nearly un-filmable book. You can’t translate the words (loved by many readers of all ages) into a typical movie. Onscreen, Gatsby’s dialogue is stilted and comes off as fake. (It’s supposed to be like that, as he’s playing a role he wasn’t born into. Jay Gatz’s roots are very humble.)
Tom, Myrtle, & Nick party in NYC hotel
Nick (Tobey Maguire), a bit younger and more naïve than the other character, is drawn into Gatsby’s world of glittering parties, beautiful/famous women, and freely flowing alcohol. After WWI (“The Roaring 20s”), Nick wants to be a writer, but ends up taking a job on Wall Street (stockbroker). He rents a little cottage beside Gatsby’s opulent mansion and wonders what’s going on inside. Finally, he gets to meet Jay Gatsby, who has a strong/emotional connection to his cousin Daisy (Carey Mulligan).
Gatsby waits nervously for Daisy’s arrival at tea
As readers know, everything Gatsby has done has been to be worthy in the eyes of Daisy, who hails from one of the “old families” of Kentucky. They met several years ago, when Gatsby’s roots were hidden under his soldier’s uniform (“a great equalizer”). She’s now married to a former polo player from old money, Tom Buchanan (Joel Edgerton). However, Tom is cheating on her with Myrtle Wilson (Isla Fisher), the wife of his mechanic.
Not even a box-office powerhouse like Leonardo DiCaprio can save this film! It’s too much- too bright/colorful, noisy, and doesn’t really go anywhere. “It looked like Disney Land- cartoonish,” one viewer commented after the screening. Maguire does what he can with what he’s given. Edgerton makes Tom a blowhard and jerk (as needed), but it’s pretty much a one-note performance. Mulligan’s talents are wasted here; she has zero chemistry with DiCaprio. For those who came to see Bollywood star Amitabh Bachchan- he doesn’t have much to do, but looks cool in those period outfits.
Daisy sees Gatsby’s house for the first time.
The director’s vision comes across (very obviously), but it’s style over substance. The disjointed (modern) music may be the biggest flaw of all! Laughs were elicited by the audience at some un-funny moments, I recall. I was wondering: Where is this all going? Some of my friends loved the book, so they may re-read it. There are so many themes to explore in this little story, but I fear this film won’t inspire the younger generation to look into the book. If you want to see Luhrmann’s best film, check out his debut work- Strictly Ballroom.
I saw the film this past Saturday (National Geographic Society); it was part of DC Film Fest. It will be in wide release (US) on Friday, April 26.
Running Time: 146 minutes
Languages:English, Hindi, Urdu
Director:Deepa Mehta (the Canadian Indian filmmaker of Bollywood Hollywood, Earth, Fire, Water, & more)
Screenwriters:Salman Rushdie (British Indian author of the novel; he also does the narration) & Mehta
Starring:Shabana Azmi (Indian; internationally-acclaimed veteran actress), Seema Biswas (Indian; co-starred in Water), Rahul Bose (Indian; indie film actor), Samrat Chakrabarti (British American actor/musician; co-starred in Season 3 of HBO’s In Treatment), Sarita Choudhury (British American; recently seen in Showtime’s Homeland), Charles Dance (British; currently seen on HBO’s Game of Thrones), Khulbushan Kharbanda (Indian veteran actor), Anupam Kher (Indian veteran actor; recently seen in Silver Linings Playbook), Zaib Shaykh (Canadian Pakistani; recently starred on Little Mosque on the Prairie), & several newcomers from the worldwide South Asian diaspora
Director of Cinematography:Giles Nuttgens (British; has worked on all of Mehta’s films)
About 400 films are made in the U.S. each year. Even more (600) are made in India. But, did you know that about 100 films are made in Indonesia each year? The Indonesian ambassador to the U.S.,Dr. Dino Patti Jalal, and his wife were joined by the Singaporean ambassador’s wife, actorNicholas Saputra(star of Joni’s Promise), and members of his staff during the first film showing. Recently, Dr. Jalal met with Hollywood director Michael Mann, who will be shooting his film, The Philosopher, in Jakarta. The film’s lead actor will be Aussie actor, Chris Hemsworth.
Lovely Man (2011)
A daughter gets to know her absentee father for one night
This is a 75 minute film, but it packs some big punches. (It won many awards in Asia.) It focuses on the relationship between a transvestite streetwalker in Jakarta and a small-town/devout Muslim teen, who just happen to be father and daughter. Without telling her mother, Cahaya (Raihaanun), travels by train to see the father who left home many years back. Cahaya is dressed conservatively and wears a white hijab (headscarf). When she gets off the train, she stops at a mosque to wash and pray. She’s amazed by the sights and sounds of the big city, as she goes in search of her father’s address. (This film uses shadow and lights very well.) At the side of a bridge, she talks to some women (who are obviously streetwalkers). She meets Ipuy (Donny Damara)- dressed in long wig, sparkly red dress, and high heels (reminiscent of some of the characters in the films of Pedro Almodovar). Needless to say, they are both shocked.
Actor Donny Damara accepting an award
Ipuy wants nothing to do with Cahaya- his life is tough enough as it is. Most people look at him with disgust and treat him unfairly. What would a hijabi like her know about someone like him? (Eventually, Cahaya takes off her hijab, to make her father more comfortable.) She’s carrying a secret, which is giving her much worry. Cahaya exclaims that she needs a father to talk to about important matters. What she doesn’t know is that some gangsters are after Ipuy for stealing a lot of cash.
Joni’s Promise (2005)
Joni goes through a LOT in one day
This funny, light-hearted film is considered to be “one of the first comedies made in Indonesia.” (It reminded me of a French comedy.) A 22 year-old man, Joni (Nicholas Saputra) delivers film reels- a job he likes and considers to be quite important. One afternoon, she sees a very pretty girl standing in line at the theater, but he’s too nervous to talk to her. We learn that she’s with her boyfriend (an entitled rich kid). She gets fed up with her guy, so she goes out. She notices Joni’s good nature and they have a chat. She doesn’t get her name or get give his out. The girl says that they can talk more of he gets done with his deliveries on time. Joni is happy with that- he’s never had a girlfriend yet. Joni’s motorbike gets stolen, he witnesses childbirth, gets a walk-on role in a film, plays the drums, and meets a mysterious artist. Can he make it back to the theater to have his first date?
IMDB photo of actor Nicholas Saputra
The Dancer (2011)
Srintil and Rasus share some fruit
This is a full-length historical drama based on a trilogy of novels. The story focuses on the love between two young people in the village of Dukuh Paruk in Java. As a small child, the parents of Srintil are killed by some fellow villagers, who believed that they were poisoning food. The ronngeng (village dancer) also died- she ate the food.
The teenaged Srintil (Prisia Nasution) and Rasus (Oka Antara) love each other deeply, though they are poor, illiterate, and don’t have many prospects. Rasus works in the rice paddy fields, like the other young men. However, Srintil thinks that she may have the spirit and the talent to become ronggeng. Her grandfather champions her cause, even though they are first met with doubt and derision.The local dance master won’t come to see Srintil perform.
Srintil goes through various rituals to become ronggeng
Rasus has a little dagger-like object which belonged to the former ronggeng. After he presents it to Srintil, everyone proclaims her to be the next ronngeng. She will not only dance , but belong to the village. Her virginity will be sold to the highest bidder- a fact that greatly upsets Rasus. (The elderly blind drummer is the only older person who senses what is going on with the couple.) Rasus runs away to the nearest town, then meets with a military commander (who thinks he could one day become a “loyal” soldier).
Srintil realizes that Rasus has joined the military
Srintil has to go through various rituals, aided by the dance master’s wife. Men bring goats, cows, and money to present to her grandfather and teacher. Before the “deflowering” ceremony, Rasus returns and they sneak off together. Later that night, Srintil pushes him away, explaining that she can’t run away with him forever. (We know that she has status and money in her community now.)
Srintil shines as a dancer (but not in her personal life)
While Srintil adapts to the lifestyle of a dancer, Rasus adapts to that of a soldier. His superiors look on him well and he finally learns to read. He crosses paths with Srintil on very few occasions. They only spend one more night together, but their lives must always be separate. When Srintil urges him to come back to the village and offers money to start his own business, Rasus refuses (too proud).
A (Communist) man from the city comes to talk to the villagers, but they only want more food, and don’t grasp what allegiance to his ideas truly mean. (In fact, 1965-1966 was a very bloody year was Indonesia’s history. Many people, who were thought to be Communist or sympathizers, were killed by the military.) This man also wants Srintil and village musicians to perform at his rallies.
Rasus and Srintil meet after the 1965 war
This film is very powerful! It won the 2011 Best Picture award in Indonesia and was submitted for a Foreign Film Academy Award. It just draws you in with it’s setting, characters, and values (which are quite different from those of urbanized, modern Indonesia). The love story starts out very gently and innocently, then we see the darker aspects (depression, frustration, etc.)- this pair must stay apart because of Srintil’s chosen path. Being a village dancer was being above others- connected to the gods (ancestors.)
Dance brings two troubled people together in this (unlikely) hit film
The silver lining is actually the fact that there is an audience for sensitive/grown-up films like this one! Bradley Cooper (never overacting) and Jennifer Lawrence (a naturally gifted actress) fall in love, despite their respective issues (hey, we all got’em). This is shot like a ’60s film, an avid moviegoer in my office said, with long takes. It’s a treat to see DeNiro, who looks to be in fine form (and great shape, too). Chris Tucker gets a few funny moments, but doesn’t overdo it. Who says the psychological issues can’t be dealt with using humor!? (The only odd note was the racial incident involving the therapist, his fellow Indian football fans, and some angry white guys.) Also, there is a great interview w/ director David O. Russell on Fresh Air w/ Terry Gross (NPR) that I recommend you listen to.
Kai po che! (2013)
Indians going crazy for cricket (as usual)
This is a film for folks who avoid (or even abhor) typical Bollywood fare. Why? It’s well-acted (no joke), well-written, and just keeps your attention (watchable). There is a bit of romance and great music, too. It’s about three idealistic friends (more like brothers) who open a sports store in the city of Ahmedabad. One has the business savvy, the other a passion for cricket, and the third procures a loan. They also discover a pre-teen cricket prodigy (Muslim) who they nurture. Then, a series of (true) events occur which affect all their lives deeply. Check this film out!